Playtesting the Lamplighters

Playtesting for Guild ball has been an absolute joy. Having playtested for a few companies now, I can say that my involvement in the community project has been pretty great. Contact between rules and testers has been consistent, regular, and (crucially) more transparent than many companies are able to be. This has helped the approach to playtesting greatly as we are able to quickly establish intent and the rules committee have been able to get quick feedback on potential places to clarify wording, giving us more energy to devote to testing of rules themselves.

For example, Lens Flare went through a few rewrites to make it clear that you could use Bonus Time! to return your dice pool to equal base stat but not to go above.

The testing of those rules has also been interesting and thanks to the playbook more involved than many previous systems I have tested. To give folks an idea of how we would test this before a game we would decide on a couple of things:

Will we allow re-rolls to try to remove poor dice affecting thoughts?

If you have a 70% expectation to roll 2 successes and get none will the testsers allow a reroll to see the "likely" result rather than a dud result? There is value in allowing rerolls and running a normal game, a normal game can usually be completed quicker and will match the rhythm of Guild ball more closely however allowing the rerolls in theory allows you to see what the majority of games should shape up to be. Individual testers would use a % they felt most comfortable with if they tried this.

Are we testing a specific interaction/idea in this game?

How much work can Nightlight (the Lamplighters captain) do if she is supplied with a full 6 influence every turn or even how do the Lamplighters work on the receive, agreeing pre game that no kick roll would be made to test this. This can allow you to push the limits of individual pieces and make a hard push on seeing if the guild has problems in certain areas, either being too good or not good enough in areas, in ways that a normal game may not try as it is risky. This lead to a few things coming forward needing to be addressed that I think Rules did a great job improving.


Part of the changes this process lead to was the removal of a guild rule which initially changed a model's stats based on whether it was suffering the burning condition or not. This was replaced by something more similar to the Ratcatchers' dilemma where there's a theme across the team of traits that models gain when suffering burning. Prior to this change, many models had an "on/off" feel which was thematic and cool but resulted in confusing board states for players. Playbooks can also be made more consistent since TAC values aren't constantly changing due to the guild rule any more. Many other changes occurred along the way which have helped streamline the team's overall design.

While some of you may know me for my use of Union (lets face it, mostly vGreede) my favourite ball team is alchemists and I am excited to see the Lamplighters hit the table as I think they feel very Alchemist. I'm looking forward to seeing how the play ups change things for alchs and how the wider community enjoy Lamplighters. I think it will have been worth the wait.

Permalink to this article


 all  Guild Ball (41)  Malifaux (1)  WTC (9)  WTC announcements (5)  administration (6)  alchemists (5)  blacksmiths (2)  brewers (2)  butchers (2)  championships (2)  community project (12)  cooks (1)  events (3)  fan fiction (3)  fishermen (1)  getting started (3)  hunters (1)  lamplighters (3)  masons (2)  match report (1)  miners (2)  morticians (2)  navigators (1)  patch notes (3)  strategy (6)


Tagged: Guild Ball

Playtesting the Lamplighters
Alun Barfoot (2021-09-13)

Niels Hermkens (2021-09-08)

Beta Testlighters
Steve Cole (2021-09-06)

Season 4.4 Patch
Niels Hermkens (2021-06-08)

Unexpected Arrival
Brian Andersen (2021-04-01)

A New Challenger Appears!
Dominic Westerland (2021-02-28)

Digital World Championship 2021
Sam Bredeson (2021-02-02)

Community Project Town Hall Meeting
Sam Bredeson (2021-01-25)

Community Project OPD
Eoin Dornan (2020-10-27)

Guild Ball community project committees
Sam Bredeson (2020-09-22)

Introducing the community project steering group
Steve Cole (2020-09-02)

Guild Ball is dead. Long live Guild Ball!
Steve Cole (2020-08-21)

Event plays 'Nimble'
Skerolf Dickinger (2020-05-06)

Kubla Con Golden Horde Virtual Tournament
Michal Rudzki (2020-04-28)

Put the event back in coach!
Skerolf Dickinger (2020-04-19)

Season 4.3 patch notes
Sam Bredeson (2020-03-30)

Momentous Victory: Masons vs Cooks
Anthony Moore (2020-03-25)

WTC 2020 - Team USA update 1
Sam Bredeson (2020-02-29)

2020 Championship Series
Sam Bredeson (2020-02-17)

WTC 2020 - Team England
Jamie Perkins (2020-01-31)

WTC 2020 - Team USA
Sam Bredeson (2020-01-23)

WTC applications open!
Skerolf Dickinger (2020-01-22)

Understanding the Goal Kick
Jacob Frelinger (2019-12-13)

At Your Post [Range: enough!]
Skerolf Dickinger (2019-11-21)

A Well Oiled Machine [Global Aura]
Skerolf Dickinger (2019-11-09)

WTC Match Reports
Jamie Perkins (2019-10-05)

Momentous Victory: Miners vs Butchers
Anthony Moore (2019-09-09)

Season 4.2 patch notes
Sam Bredeson (2019-08-12)

The Ash Cup: Broken
Richard Bailey (2019-07-09)

Scouting Report: Brewers
Rhiannon Morrison (2019-05-28)

Guild Spotlight: Brewers
Rhiannon Morrison (2019-05-20)

Scouting Report: Blacksmiths
Rhiannon Morrison (2019-05-13)

Guild Spotlight: Blacksmiths
Rhiannon Morrison (2019-05-06)

Scouting Report: Alchemists
Rhiannon Morrison (2019-04-29)

Critical Moments or How to Win at Guild Ball
Henry Kay (2019-04-25)

Guild Spotlight: Alchemists
Rhiannon Morrison (2019-04-22)

Gettin' into Guild Ball
Alex Botts (2019-04-10)

Superior Strategy #1 - Activations
Evan Lewis (2019-04-05)

A Top-down Look at Turn One
Rhiannon Morrison (2019-04-03)

Dice Intensity and the Miners
Alex Botts (2019-03-29)

The Ball and Victory Points as Resources
Jacob Mortenson (2019-03-27)

The views and opinions expressed in Blogshanks articles are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the official position of Longshanks.


Choose a game system


Log in


Don't have a profile? Create one